By John W. Schiemann
While the Senate published its so-called "Torture record" in December 2014 the realm could research that, for years, the CIA had used unimaginably brutal the way to interrogate its prisoners - usually with out yielding any priceless or fair info. The employer had lengthy and adamantly defended its use of torture, staunchly arguing that it was once not just simply yet important for the country's safeguard. or even amid the revelations of the document, questions abound approximately even if torture might be thought of a justifiable instrument of nationwide protection.
Is interrogational torture a good approach to extracting info? How sturdy does the data extracted must be for the torture to be thought of profitable? How frequently or how vigorously needs to torture be used to accomplish necessary details? it can be the case that interrogational torture can by no means be justified below any conditions, yet, based on John Schiemann, whether it is to be justified in any respect, it has to be potent. based on a couple of nationwide ballot, such a lot american citizens do think that torture can paintings, and that it may be justified below convinced situations. but when the data that torturers extract is undesirable, then the tactic quantities to not anything greater than natural sadism. So, how do we clear up the difficulty over even if to torture or to not torture?
In this e-book, John Schiemann takes a really special approach to the query of torture: video game conception. deliberating torture as a "game" performed among an interrogator and a detainee, the publication walks the reader during the good judgment of interrogational torture, evaluating the results to the claims made by way of torture proponents. The ebook attracts on a wide selection of resources starting from files of the Inquisition to mystery CIA memos to track this good judgment, illustrating each one final result of the version with a story from the genuine international of interrogational torture. Does Torture Work? is an soaking up and provocative tackle one in every of such a lot mentioned human rights and safety dilemmas of our time.
Read or Download Does Torture Work? PDF
Best intelligence & espionage books
White condo speechwriter Marc Thiessen used to be locked in a safe room and given entry to the main delicate intelligence while he was once tasked to put in writing President George W. Bush’s 2006 speech explaining the CIA’s interrogation software and why Congress may still authorize it. Few recognize extra approximately those CIA operations than Thiessen, and in his new ebook, relationship catastrophe, he records simply how powerful the CIA’s interrogations have been in foiling assaults on the US, penetrating al-Qaeda’s excessive command, and offering our army with actionable intelligence.
On a moonless evening simply weeks after September eleven, 2001, U. S. specific Forces group ODA 574 infiltrates the mountains of southern Afghanistan with a doubtless most unlikely venture: to foment a tribal rebel and strength the Taliban to give up. Armed completely with the apparatus they could keep it up their backs, shockingly scant intelligence, and their mastery of guerrilla war, Captain Jason Amerine and his males don't have any selection yet to belief their in basic terms best friend, a little-known Pashtun statesman named Hamid Karzai who has lower back from exile and is being hunted by means of the Taliban as he travels the nation-state elevating a defense force.
Lately declassified facts and never-before-translated records inform the genuine tale of the day that FDR memorably declared might dwell in infamy, exploring how Joseph Stalin and the KGB used an enormous community of double brokers and communist sympathizers—most particularly Harry Dexter White—to lead Japan into battle opposed to the USA, providing Soviet involvement at the back of the bombing of Pearl Harbor.
This booklet tracks submit September 11 advancements in nationwide safety and policing intelligence and their relevance to new rising parts of intelligence perform corresponding to: corrections, biosecurity, deepest and regulatory environments. advancements are explored thematically throughout 3 vast sections: making use of intelligence realizing buildings constructing a self-discipline.
Additional resources for Does Torture Work?
The “tough” statements of Bush administration and CIA officials about going to the “dark side” and the “gloves coming off” suggest that what they have really objected to was the possibility of legal proceedings, not the fact of torture itself. 1. December 2014 Huffington Post/YouGov Survey on Torture Techniques Technique Slapping/punching Walling Nudity Sleep deprivation Waterboarding Threatening detainee’s family Threatening detainee with violence Confinement box for days Rectal feeding Acceptable 44 40 37 55 35 30 31 28 11 Unacceptable 35 41 44 30 45 55 51 52 73 Not Sure 21 19 19 16 20 15 18 20 16 Dangerous Torment 33 9/11, an attack they thought imminent, one can sympathize with their dilemma.
Coffman testified that he knew nothing about the money, but told two lies to stop the torture, and eventually the deputies stopped. 4 Accused of taking San Jacincto County Sheriff James Parker’s tractor, Hicks denied knowing anything about it. Parker responded that Hicks would be “begging to tell them where the tractor was” and Hicks was taken to a small holding cell in the back of the jail. After half an hour, Hicks was made to change into white coveralls and then, after about another half hour, he was taken by Deputy Baker to a detox cell.
The manacles made it difficult to keep up with the guards. Inside the room they adjusted his chains in order to shackle him to a chair. The room was cold and he requested clothes. They ignored him. When they removed the hood and blindfold, he blinked and squinted, for the room was all white and very brightly lit. The only other object in the room beside the chair was a bucket and a horizontal bar over his head near the ceiling. One of the masked ninjas told him they’d be back soon to question him and that Khalid would be given one chance to cooperate with them.